I went to go buy some today at my local drug store and was faced with a plethora of different brands. I spent a few minutes contemplating what to do.
The "store brand" featured a package of of 24 roles, and there was also a package of 12 roles of chlorine-free, recycled bathroom tissue with less packing and - both for about $6. From a financial standpoint you'd think that the store brand would be a better call, but after a little investigating, I found out that the recycled brand was actually the better call.
The "store brand" featured a package of of 24 roles, and there was also a package of 12 roles of chlorine-free, recycled bathroom tissue with less packing and - both for about $6. From a financial standpoint you'd think that the store brand would be a better call, but after a little investigating, I found out that the recycled brand was actually the better call.
Not only was the recycled TP made from 100% recycled fiber diverted from landfills, but each roll had 354 sheets on it - compared with the store brand that only had 150. So when you calculate it all out, the store brand 24-pack was 3600 -ish sheets of TP on 24 cardboard rolls with nearly twice as much plastic wrapping, compared to the recycled brand that had 4248 sheets on only 12 cardboard roles (and half the plastic wrapping!). If you think about it even more, since the whole package of the recycled brand was nearly half that of the store-brand, it took less room in the transport truck.
In the end, I went for the 100% recycled, chlorine-free brand. So, I suppose my point for today is to do a little research on your products. My challenge is to spend a little bit more time contemplating the products that you buy and reading the labels and doing the math. Even when it comes to toilet paper.
Reading labels is also important for things that call themselves "green" - what does that really mean anyways? Be skeptical of things with labels like "natural", "green" and "safe" -they can mean just about anything and are often misused to mislead consumers.
David Suzuki's green guide gives these suggestions for finding more environmentally friendly products in the mess of trendy "greenwash"
David Suzuki's green guide gives these suggestions for finding more environmentally friendly products in the mess of trendy "greenwash"
"First, check for certification by a respected organization. Second, be skeptical about vague claims. [...] Third, look for specific details. The three green arrows symbol and the word 'recycle' or 'recyclable' mean that a product is recyclable but not that it is made of recycled content. If the label says 'recycled', look for how much of the content is recycled. There's a big difference between 5% and 100%. Fourth, context is important. A 'recyclable' product won't be recycled unless it's included in your community program. A 'biodegradable' product will not biodegrade if you put it in the garbage, since even food and paper may not break down in landfills. You can get full details on all the various claims made on product labels from Consumer Reports at www.greenerchoices.org" (99)
Have you made or had trouble making any similar decisions?
Happy Monday!
Happy Monday!
Hey, you can do even better: don't use any TP, just wash your rear with warm water and a bit of soap - much cleaner and cheaper! However, you'll ask "Where the heck do you want me to wash, in the kitchen sink or in the shower?!" Well, you'll have to install a cute little device called bidet that can cost as much as $1000... My point is thar there is always another way to do things and maybe this other way is more environmentally friendly.
ReplyDeleteHi Paul,
ReplyDeleteIt would be interesting to see how the production, shipping, heating of of water, installation, water use, maintenance and disposal of the bidet compared to more traditional methods. Also, according to a quick google search, Bidets are traditionally used in conjunction with toilet paper -thus not being as sustainable as your post indicates.
If you are concerned about finances and feel that I am encouraging people to spend more money, I would like to point out that the 100% recycled TP that I mentioned in my blog post actually ended up being more economical than the store brand when you did the math.
Furthermore, home renovations to the extent that you suggest are outside of my capabilities as a renter and outside the scope of this blog. This blog is about small things that the everyday person can do to reduce their carbon footprint. They may not always be the most radical or all-encompassing solution, but, as I mentioned before, if many people are doing it, every little bit counts.
Cheers,
Heidi
OK, now the engineer in you kicks in life and starts to take all factors into account. Good! And I agree with your comments, with one small exception: No, one should not use TP after using the bidet, it's not needed as your bum should be squeacky cleanby then, just wipe with a towel. How do I know? I have one at home!!!
ReplyDeleteP.